Poor Tom is Cold
By: Maureen Jennings
The main character in the novel, “Poor Tom is Cold”, is detective William Murdoch. Murdock is an active detective for police station number four in Toronto, Ontario. No specific date is mentioned in the novel, but it is clear that it is set around the 1890s. Murdoch is a middle-aged man who lives with his two landlords and his fellow border and her son in a downtown Toronto house. A few years back, Murdoch lost the love of his life and he still thinks about her and misses her daily. One of the storylines in the novel is his relationship with his fellow border, Ms. Jones. He quite likes Ms. Jones, and she likes him too. There is one problem however, she is a Baptist and he is Roman-Catholic. By today’s standards this wouldn’t really be a problem but back then it would have been a big deal. At the police station were he works, Murdoch is well liked and respected by his colleagues and is regarded as a very clever and witty individual. The main story line in the novel is the investigation of the death of one of the constables at station number four. Late one night, some of the police staff noticed that constable Oliver Wicken had not returned from his late night shift. Murdoch is sent to go look for the young constable. He eventually finds Wicken dead in the kitchen of an abandoned house. Wicken has been shot and it looks like he did it himself. Everyone is ready to call it a suicide and be done with it. Murdoch knew Oliver and he doesn’t think he would have done something like this. This shows that Murdoch isn’t lazy about getting into a complicated case and he cared about Oliver and what will happen to his family. Discrimination is a prominent theme through out the novel but at many times Murdoch goes beyond this and just listens to what people have to say. One of the witnesses at the trial was Chinese. Many people accused him of lying just because he was not English, but Murdoch puts race aside and really hears what has said. The info from the Chinaman eventually helped Murdoch to solve the case.
Through out the whole novel there were many clues left behind. The mystery part of the novel is that it looks like Oliver Wicken committed suicide, but many think he did not. Right off the bat the author leaves a clue about how Wicken died. For the first chapter, the novel talks about a family, the Eakins, who live near where Wicken died. This family is described as having lots of problems and there are lots of things going on in all of their lives. It is obvious that one of them is somehow connected to the crime. Another bit of early evidence that it was not a murder was the position of Oliver’s gun. When he was dead, his gun was stuck in between his legs. It would have been very odd for the gun to have fallen in a position like that. There is another big clue later on in the novel involving the Chinaman and one of the witnesses. In court the Chinaman directly says that the girl presented was the one he saw with Oliver on the night of his death. Later on he tells his son in secrecy that it was actually a different woman. This is very confusing, as the Chinaman had no reason to lie. This shakes things up mid-way through the novel and keeps you guessing. Other then that there are relatively few clues until the last few pages of the novel. One of the Eakins tried to kill the main witness with a shotgun and then it becomes apparent that he was responsible for the death of Oliver.
“All three women were in the same position. A canvas cover was stretched across the iron tub. There was a hole for the patient’s head; the rest of the body was completely immersed. There was a canvas harness that sloped backwards and Peg was fastened to it by a strap at the waist. Her arms were tied at the wrists and her legs were similarly restrained at the ankles. The bonds weren’t tight but she knew she couldn’t slip out of them. Even if she had been able to get loose, she never would have been able to lift the canvas cover because it was tied to rings at the side of the tub.” (p. 79)
I think this is a good passage for a few reasons. One, it is very well written, and two, it is very creepy. This passage was very well written. I can clearly make out what this scene would have looked like, and even felt like. The fact that the description of this passage is so vivid just adds to the creepiness of it. I am a bit of a claustrophobic so being tied down in a rather small space would be quite scary to begin with. Since she is tied down in water this is even more frightening, if somehow she got her head caught under the cover she could easily drown and that would be an unbelievably painful death.
“In your opinion, was there anything at all in Wicken that would have indicated a man with suicidal tendencies? Absolutely not. He was always a good-natured fellow. If I may add, in all my experience as a police officer I have never known a pistol to end up stick between a mans legs the way it was found…” (P.118)
I liked this passage because it really sums up Murdoch’s doubts about Oliver’s suicide. Everyone is so quick to just call it a suicide but Murdoch isn’t ready to call it quits and threw his determination he eventually solves the case.
“Darkness was well settled in and the street lamps were struggling with out much success to throw out some light in the gloom. A few passersby, bent under their black umbrellas, hurried to get out of the drizzle that has started up again. Murdoch had started a Queen street, knocking on every single door, and it had taken him almost two hours. He was tired and disheartened and his mouth felt dry from too much talking.” (p. 256)
This is a great passage. It describes an awful sounding night prowling the streets of Toronto. You can easily see how uncomfortable Murdoch is. He is cold, tired, and wet while we’re just sitting on a couch. I found it made me appreciate where I was at that moment and how I felt.
No comments:
Post a Comment